New Irish subject rejected
September 9, 2010
A chara, – Hurray for Minister for Education Mary Coughlan for ploughing ahead with 40 per cent of the marks for Irish in the Leaving Cert being awarded for the oral examination (Home News, August 31st).
I have no doubt but that teachers and students alike will rise to the challenge and that as a result Irish will become a popular subject.
Could the Minister not spare a thought, however, for the fluent speaker who will sit bored through Irish class? Is Irish doomed to become the only official EU language where its native speakers are not meaningfully exposed to its literature and challenged at second-level?
It was proposed to offer an optional subject of “Irish literature/translation studies” to challenge and round off the second-level education of fluent and native speakers, but this was rejected as giving a minority an extra subject.
We all rejoice in families who practise music at home and never grumble if their children take music as an extra Leaving Cert subject.
Neither do we grumble where students with Russian or French at home pick up extra honours in these subjects. Is the anti-Irish bias really so strong in the Department of Education to deny this educational need of Irish speaking children? – Is mise,
DÁITHÍ Mac CÁRTHAIGH BL
Gaeltacht Ráth Chairn,
Baile Átha Buí,
Co na Mí.
The Irish Times – Litir chuig an Eagarthóir
09 Meán Fómhair 2010
Buntáiste Breise na Gaeilge
September 8, 2010
Brú le Gaelcholáiste úr a bhunú i ndeisceart Bhaile Átha Cliath
September 8, 2010
Aitheantas Sealadach Gaelcholáiste Charraig Uí Laighean
September 7, 2010
Dul Chun Cinn i Ráth Tó
September 7, 2010
Bilingual FG
September 7, 2010
I welcome the fact that Fine Gael now has a section for primary and secondary school students on their website.
However, given that we have 169 primary and 38 second level gaelscoileanna on the island outside of the Gaeltacht, surely the party should have a bilingual website?
Darren Prior
Baile atha Cliath 15
The Irish Independent – Litir chuig an Eagarthóir
07 Meán Fómhair 2010
Irish-speaking children don’t get a fair deal
September 7, 2010
Hurrah for Education Minister Mary Coughlan who is ploughing ahead with 40% of the marks for Irish in the Leaving Cert being awarded for the oral examination.
I have no doubt teachers and students alike will rise to the challenge and that, as a result, Irish will become a popular subject. Could the minister not spare a thought, however, for the fluent speaker who will sit bored through Irish class? Is Irish doomed to become the only official EU language where its native speakers are not meaningfully exposed to its literature and challenged at second level?
It was proposed to offer an optional subject of Irish Literature/Translation Studies to challenge and round off the second-level education of fluent and native speakers, but this was rejected as giving a minority an extra subject.
We all rejoice in families who practise music at home and never grumble if their children take music as an extra Leaving Cert subject.
Neither do we grumble when students with Russian or French at home pick up extra honours in these subjects.
Is the anti-Irish bias really so strong in the Department of Education as to deny this educational need of Irish-speaking children?
Daithí Mac Cárthaigh
Gaeltacht Rath Chairn
Baile Átha Buí
Co na Mí
The Irish Examiner – Litir chuig an Eagarthóir
07 Meán Fómhair 2010
Buntáiste Breise na Gaeilge ar chamchuairt!
September 7, 2010
ESRI warns schools over ghetto risk to immigrants
September 7, 2010
A leading think-tank has warned of the dangers of increasing ghettoisation of schools in Ireland.
The ESRI says half of immigrant primary pupils are in schools with large numbers of children from overseas – where they make up more than 20pc of the student population.
In comparison, 40pc of the country’s 3,300 primary schools have no immigrants at all.
Immigrants are more likely to attend designated disadvantaged schools. The differences between disadvantaged and non-disadvantaged schools can be quite stark — they imply an increasing ghettoisation of those schools designated as disadvantaged.
Immigrants are under-represented in Gaelscoileanna, mainly because of the reluctance of non-English speaking families to learn an additional new language. Higher proportions are found in urban and larger schools and in designated disadvantaged schools.
The study, entitled ‘Immigration and School Composition in Ireland’ was written by ESRI researchers Delma Byrne, Frances McGinnity, Emer Smyth and Merike Darmody and published in ‘Irish Educational Studies’.
They carried out a survey of 735 primary and 448 second-level schools. The study shows there is greater diversity of nationalities in schools here than in other European countries. Around 10pc of primary pupils — 45,700 — are immigrant, while there are 18,000 in post-primary, or 6pc. About 70pc of immigrant students are non-English speaking.
Preference
Nine out of 10 second-level schools have immigrant pupils, but many have small percentages of between 2pc and 9pc.
The ESRI says that enrolment criteria in Irish schools tend to favour settled communities, particularly where parents are required to sign up well in advance and preference is given to the siblings of those already in the school.
Much migration is relatively recent and many immigrants are very mobile. As a result, children will end up in schools that are under-subscribed. Irish parents with ‘insider’ knowledge of the educational system are more likely to successfully negotiate access to their preferred school. In contrast, immigrant parents can be ‘outsiders’ in terms of knowing how the system operates.
The Irish National Teachers’ Organisation (INTO) said that immigrant children were losing vital teaching support because of cuts in the number of English language teachers.
The union said that last year the Government cut nearly 500 of these teaching jobs in primary schools and predicted that a similar number could be cut this year. It said this was because of a hardline approach by the Department of Education and Skills, which had limited English language teaching to two years.
INTO general secretary Sheila Nunan said: “Two years is only enough for children to develop surface understanding of a language.
“To get to a standard where newcomer children can learn subjects like science and geography through English takes a further five to seven years.”
John Walshe Education Editor
Irish Independent
Sárthorthaí á ngnóthú ag Gaeilgeoirí óga ó thuaidh
September 3, 2010
